Do You Want Cream With That? – Creamy Color Choices Today

I started drinking coffee just after starting my first job out of college. I was working as an estimator/project manager trainee for an electrical contractor in Syracuse. One early morning in January, I found myself on a job site, freezing my tail off and gladly accepting the offer of a cup. Lots of cream and sugar made it possible to drink and I was grateful for the warmth it provided. It’s amazing how fast an addiction can take hold. From that day forward, I was a coffee drinker.

Later, I moved to Boston and took a job with an electrical distributor. Every morning, a catering truck would pull into the warehouse and we would all line up for coffee and donuts. This is where I learned that if you want black coffee in Boston, the correct way to order it is “regular, no cream, no sugar”. And what, you ask, does this have to do with cars? Well, if you haven’t guessed by now, stay with me and I will tell you.

I’ve always had a fondness for small, cheap cars. No luxury for me. My first car was a 1965 Opel Kadett L. About as cheap as you could find in 1971 unless you opted for the basic Kadett. From there I owned a VW Beetle, Toyota Corolla, Dodge Colt…you get the idea. If it was under 2 liters and had a manual gearbox, I was interested. In 2011 I was shopping for a replacement for my 2007 Mazda 3 hatchback.

Around this time, Scion introduced their updated TC and I was drawn to the Release Series 7.0 in this amazing shade of yellow called High Voltage. According to Wikipedia, only 2,200 were produced and I never saw one in real life.

After giving up on ever finding a yellow TC, I shifted my attention to locating a TC in this new color called Cement. Ultimately, I passed on the TC and I regret that to this day, but this was the beginning of my interest in this type of paint. Not metallic, not flat, but a rich, creamy shade of gray.  While variations on this non-metallic paint are quite ubiquitous now, this was quite a new thing in 2011. In fact, Scion might have been the first to introduce it. Sort of like getting just the right amount of cream in that coffee.

Of course, since then, many other makes have jumped on board. Starting with Audi and their 2013 shade called Nardo Gray. Hmmm, it kind of looks like Cement. Maybe a touch more blue.

And here’s Ford’s Leadfoot, circa 2018.

Honda joined the fray in 2017 with a variation on the gray called Sonic Gray Pearl. Really more of a blue than gray.

As these creamy shades started to proliferate, my wife Maggie and I started to play a little game. When we spotted one of these paint jobs we would call it yes or no. Kind of like when you don’t quite put enough cream in that coffee. It just looks wrong, so you add a splash. And heaven forbid you add too much cream. You might as well pour it out and start over. By our rules, it needs to be a variation of gray. It can be blue-gray or green-gray. But not tan. Never tan.

Yes, I realize that this Audi Q8 is actually the epitomy of a perfect coffee with cream, but no, not tan. And not this car. These creamy paints don’t work on every car.

And don’t add too much cream, then it’s just milk.

I tried to do some research on how these paints are produced and who came up with the idea first. If someone out there knows, please post in the comment section. The best answer I could come up with was something along the lines of the local paint rep showing up at Toyota one day and said “hey, take a look at this sample that the boys in the lab came up with, whaddya think?” I have noticed that some are truly non-metallic and some are not. The Audi above is showing something they call Sakhir Gold Metallic. As with all paints, lighting is the key to how they look in real life.

These two Fords are both done in Cactus Gray. I shot both at a Ford dealer on the same day. It’s hard to tell from these photos, but in real life the Maverick was a bit greener and the Bronco a bit bluer.

I’m guessing we’re reaching the age of peak cream. Like a lot of trends, there is a limited appetite for things that are different. My guess is that these colors will hit maybe 2-3% of the overall market and then consumer interest will start to wane. What I have noticed lately is newer shades, somewhat less creamy.

Like this Kia Niro in Cityscape Green. It’s still creamy, but if this were your coffee and you didn’t drink it black, you would want to add a splash more half and half.

What’s really exciting is that colors of all sorts are finally make a comeback. Here are just some of the options available on the 2024 Ford Bronco Sport. Maybe the era of black, silver, gray, and white is finally coming to a close? We can always hope!