Much has been written about how Japanese cars, especially Hondas and Toyotas, reached the zenith of their quality and refinement during the period from the late 1980s through the mid-1990s. Honda, for instance, was on an every four-year model cycle with its Accord and Civic, leapfrogging the competition and leaving hapless companies like GM lagging behind just as they thought they were catching up (Saturn- cough, cough!). Not only were the Japanese rolling out all-new models at a dizzying pace, the cars themselves were all-stars; lovingly built, highly refined, and, in some cases, eminently desirable. This is the era that gave us the Acura Legend, the Lexus LS 400, and the 4th and 5th generation Honda Accords. And by crikey, it just so happens that a 5th-generation Accord is the subject of this COAL installment.
How did Ms. D and I go from a rinky-dink crackerbox like the Saturn to one of the most vaunted Accords of all of Accord-dom? The clue is in the color: Heather Mist Metallic. What? You mean, you liked that color so much, you just had to get one? I mean, whatever rocks your funky world, Matt, but I gotta question your aesthetic preferences… No, that’s not what I mean.
You see, Ms. D’s parents bought a brand new 1996 Accord to replace their 1988 Chevy Corsica. For a comparison metaphor, that’s like going from a stone tablet and chisel to an iPad overnight, or from The Shaggs to Beyoncé. At the time, they were in their early 60s, so they chose a color that was obviously conceived for their play-it-safe, don’t-pay-attention-to-me demographic: the aforementioned Heather Mist Metallic. You can see the color clearly in the photo at top, but if you tried to describe it to someone who had never seen it, what would you say? It clearly wasn’t gold, but it wasn’t exactly silver, either. Kind of in-between? With a hint of beige? Not exactly eye candy.
Despite the ho-hum paint-job it was a fabulous car, but my father-in-law (we’ll call him “Mr. O”), soon craved more power. The Accord was equipped with Honda’s 2.2-liter SOHC four, good for about 130 horses. Not bad for the standards of the day, but not particularly powerful, either. By 2000, he had his eye on a 6th-generation Accord, specifically the one with the 200 hp 3.0L V6.
One hot summer day in Medford (which is pretty much every summer day in Medford) in 2000, Mr. and Mrs. O were down from Vancouver, Washington for a visit. Our daughter was now almost three, and they, being grandparents, couldn’t get enough of her. I was working at my computer in the kitchen while the Os chatted away with my wife. I started to overhear bits of their conversation. They were ready to buy the Accord V-6 and wanted to offer us their current Honda at a ridiculously low price. I rolled my chair into the kitchen entryway where I could look into the living room. “Oh?” I said rather nonchalantly, trying to mask the excitement brewing within. “We’d love to have the Accord. It’s certainly roomier than the Saturn (and better built, and nicer to drive, and not an embarrassment…).”
So Ms. D and I drove the Saturn (I think we strapped Miss E—our daughter—in Grandpa and Grandma’s car) up to Portland where Mr. and Mrs. O bought a new 2000 Accord V6. It sported another non-color, “signet silver metallic,” which was sort of a grayish-lavender, not unlike used chewing gum. There we gave them the Saturn to trade-in and we took possession of the ’96 Accord. Let’s just say the drive back to Medford was one of the nicest car rides we ever took as a married couple.
Compared to the Saturn, and that’s not a very fair comparison—more akin to comparing Cheetos to foie gras—the Accord oozed refinement. Honda interiors of that era were some of the best ever. Acres of soft-touch materials (especially on the dash top and door panels), switch gear and other fiddly bits that moved/clicked with a confident authority, and firm yet comfortable seats that felt like they could go the distance, which in an Accord potentially meant hundreds of thousands of miles. Driving the car felt like riding on a cloud compared to the old Saturn. No doubt it gave that impression because we had made such a drastic leap in automotive quality. In reality, the Accord was very much a compact car: there was some road noise and of course you felt some bumps and rough roads. The difference was that the Saturn complained, sometimes bitterly, about road imperfections whereas the Accord was zen-like, taking them in stride.
I knew the Accord would be an excellent car because dad traded in his ’88 Mazda for a ’92 Accord LX. There was nothing was wrong with the Mazda, he just wanted a 5-speed manual. I think that was the closest he came to buying a “mid-life crisis” car. His Honda was a sweet ride though, and I got to drive it over the Greensprings once, which was fun with a capital F. Being equipped with a 4-speed auto, our ’96 didn’t feel quite as sporty. And although it still had the double-wishbones, I swear to this day that it didn’t handle quite as nicely as dad’s Accord. Nothing bad, but it just felt like there was a tad more body roll in corners compared to the ’92. Maybe some Hondaphile here can enlighten me.
Minor complaints, though. The Accord was by far the best car we had ever owned. And now it was the family car*, soon with a crayon melted on the back seat to prove it. It served us eminently well in that capacity and it was Miss E’s taxi from ages 3 to 12. We had no problems except for the time one of the door-handle moldings cracked, but that was after 180K and thousands of tugs on the handle. Otherwise, it was just routine maintenance and the occasional new tires and batteries. One of my only complaints, if you must call it that, was that we had to be religious about changing the timing belt every 80,000 miles. Accords of that era had “interference” engines, and our mechanic drilled it into our heads to get that belt changed before it broke or else the valves would be toast. Because they had to pull the engine to change the belt (thanks, Honda), it was a $600 job. But at least we could plan for that.
Oh, wait…I do have one more gripe and it has nothing to do with the mechanics of the car. It’s that color. It’s not an offensive color; really it’s not much of a color at all. And I could have lived with it if weren’t for the fact that you couldn’t swing a dead possum in any direction without hitting another Accord painted Heather Mist Metallic. Whenever we would park in a large parking lot, there were bound to be 2-3 other identically colored ‘94-‘97 Accords, so we had to make a careful mental note of our specific spot. I almost felt like attaching some sort of tall flag to the car just to make the job easier. But that would have looked ridiculous, of course. So would swinging a dead possum, for that matter.
As with the Tercel and even the Saturn, I took this car on roads where others might have wanted a more rugged vehicle. The Accord performed more than adequately for these trips. In the summer of 2006, Dad and I made a pilgrimage to the “Sacred Fly Fishing Grounds”: Lee Thomas Meadow on the north fork of the Sprague River between Klamath Falls and Lakeview. To get there, you have to drive about 20 miles on unpaved forest service roads- both red-cinder and gravel. The location lies above 6,200 feet in elevation and is buried deep within the Fremont-Winema National Forest. After dad fished (I took photos), we took more Forest Service roads to seek out stands of impressively large Ponderosa pines.
The Honda was perfectly suited for trips into the “outback” like that. I remember about 12 years earlier, just after grandpa died, my dad and I went fishing with Carl, one of grandpa’s old fishing buddies. Carl had a 1990 Accord coupe and when we picked him up, it was sitting in his driveway. I noticed on the nose of Carl’s car constellations of dimples and pock-marks- likely from the thousands of micro-projectiles you’ll stir up by driving on the very same red cinder and gravel roads dad and I drove on during our 2006 trip. Carl saw my Dad’s Accord. “You know Rod,” Carl said in his folksy rural Oregon twang (yes, there is such a thing), “them little cars are hard to beat.” I couldn’t have said it better myself. We drove ours from 63,000 to 239,000 miles and could have probably put a lot more miles on it if not for that interference engine Achilles heel. More about that in my next installment.
*You may have noticed that in all the COALS I’ve posted so far, Ms. D and I seem to only have one car. That was very much the case until 2014, actually. How did we manage? We did just fine, thank you. Cars are expensive to own and maintain, so we didn’t get a second car until it was absolutely necessary. You’ll read about that in an upcoming COAL.
Another great post, Matt. I remember someone once mentioned that Honda had trouble deciding whether they wanted the Accord to be a sports sedan or a luxury sedan from generation to generation. That maybe explains why yours didn’t feel as sporty as your dad’s ’92, but if you’d driven a ’98-’02 it may have felt sportier as well.
Agreed, about another great post. We’ve got two terrific COALs running at the same time right now.
Yes, Honda couldn’t quite decide whether to chase the Camry/Taurus, or be a cheaper 3 Series. This generation was a bit flabbier, but the inherent Accord goodness was still there.
I drove both my Dad’s ’92 and Mr. 0’s 2000. Both felt sportier than our ’96. The ’00 had the V-6 and really crisp steering feel, but it was a larger car. My dad’s just felt like it had a perfect balance of handling, steering, and even performance in a 4-cylinder car (it was undoubtedly a little lighter than our Accord). All three were wonderful cars to own, however.
I believe many people (with the exception of movie actors, politicians, and Boss Hogg) don’t want to stand out, so “gentle” colors like Heather Mist Metallic are big sellers.
If you want to stand out, there are “Loud” colors like Subaru’s Quartz Blue Pearl where people know it’s you coming down the road even from a great distance.
“Gentle” colors usually do not show dirt as much as “Loud” colors.
There is a rumor that Police on the lookout for speeders notice “Loud” colors more than they do “Gentle” colors. YMMV.
There is a reason why real estate agents will cringe if you ask them to list a home with rooms painted in bright primary colors and they will visibly cry if the exterior of the home is painted in a “Loud” color.
Regardless of the color though, it is truly a joy to have a car that – with proper maintenance – starts, runs, and stops as expected, year after year, in a manner that feels competent, well built, and reliable. Anecdotal experiences in the past 15 years indicate to me that Honda and Toyota remain tier 1 cars just as they did in the 1980s and 1990s. Again, YMMV.
Those Ponderosa pines are spectacular; we do not have them here on the East coast. I used to love our big growth trees, but super storm Sandy in 2012 taught us to fear them when they are growing near our homes.
Ponderosa pines are pretty common in parts of the west, especially east of the Cascades. We don’t have any right where I live, sadly. But if you drive to the eastern end of the Columbia Gorge, they are easy to find, though they aren’t as large as the ones in my picture.
Rock solid cars those Accords. The timing belt on the 4 cylinder doesn’t require engine removal.
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=%23&ved=2ahUKEwitsIK51dPnAhVnvFkKHRzFBeUQwqsBMAB6BAgEEAQ&usg=AOvVaw0VTJzWxrN8ZFOD4xbU2nov
Yeah I was going to say the same thing, those are an relatively easy to change belt, once you get the crank bolt loose. Somewhere I still have the special tool to hold the balancer while you remove or install that bolt that had a very high torque spec.
The trick if you didn’t have access to air tools was to put a breaker bar on the crank bolt, wedge it against the ground, and crank the engine over. Disable the injectors so it won’t fire up.
Interesting. Maybe our mechanic was a little shady?
Sadly the 5th generation Accord is where things went south, as different market Accords diverged. The European model differed from the US and Japanese Accords and was actually built in the UK. I sometimes drove one that was on the company fleet, and though it went well the quality was lacking.
The 6th generation model was similarly, to my mind, forgettable – unless you got your hands on the identical JDM version.
Having driven 3rd-6th gen Accords as various times, this is how I would rate them:
1. 4th gen
2. 3rd and 5th (almost a tie)
4. 6th gen
This is very subjective, of course. My dad’s Accord was definitely the best and most balanced. Can’t exactly say why. Our 5th gen was impeccably built (in Marysville, Ohio, I believe), but not quite as crisp a handler. Mr. O’s 6th-gen was fun to drive with the V6, but by that time it was apparent that the faltering Japanese economy was taking its toll. The interior of his car felt cheaper than ours with a big ol’ slab of hard plastic on the dash top.
Yes there were two Accords during the 90s NZ ended up with both good cars not great but I guess it depends on what you have to compare them with, I used to drive a early 90s Toyota Corona but one you cant get outside NZ the local assembly model had a galvanised body and suspension tuning by race driver Chris Amon wider rims 4 wheel disc brakes very competent cars on twisty broken bitumen roads an Accord does not compare well, Timing belts are not an engine out job on Japanese brands somebody was scamming your wallet there Ive done a few and have yet to need to remove the engine if you want lack of space to do a timing belt I can recommend a Citroen Xsara or 306 Peugeot diesel, I have a few uniquely shaped spanners you’ll need to reach certain bolts but even on those the engine remains in place.
Among other things, I’m enjoying the familiar scenery. Love that part of Oregon, and the big ponderosas, the “redwoods” of the high desert.
I miss being in that country. My grandpa fished in that area for decades and when I came along, I got to join him. Now that my mom and dad are up in Washington near us now, we don’t get down there. I would have to say that country is where my heart is, for sure.
I spent 6 hours and hiked 6.5 miles yesterday in a new open space area in the Santa Cruz mountains, helping scout new trails to be built before it’s opened to the public. There were redwoods, ponderosas and coulter pines intermingled with oak, madrone and manzanita … according to the biologist we were with, all the conifers including the redwoods had been planted for timber but it was an unusual mix here. The pine needle carpet was feet thick in places, and the fallen cones were massive.
For those who have never seen them, coulter pine cones are massive- up to a foot long and weighing 3-5 pounds when fresh and green. I have several that I’ve collected over the years. California has many places that feature an “unusual mix” of vegetation. So do Oregon and Washington.
I can relate to the quantum leap feeling since in 2017 we went from a poverty spec 1997 Saturn SL2 to a 2016 Mazda CX-5. Between the high quality interior, modern conveniences and sharper handling it was a revelation. Granted the SL2 had more power and better handling than an SL1 but it was still noisy and had crank windows and manual door locks.
The last Accord I drove was a 2nd gen and while I appreciated the refinement over the 1st gen cars even with a 5 speed it didn’t feel eager and the handling was blah. I guess the next few generations fixed that. Personally I don’t like the looks of the 5th gen car as much as other years because I miss the quarter windows in the rear door. The one piece glass seems bland and unfinished. If I had to pick a US market Accord variant to daily I think I’d actually go for an Acura TSX since they used the European Accord platform.
Moving up to the Accord from the Saturn has kept me firmly in the buy Japanese camp (even if it’s made here) ever since. I’ve never regretted it.
Scratched a balance shaft while replacing its seal while doing a timing belt on my ’96 wagon. Had a hard time tracking down the leak so I ended up R&R’ing the belt three times. I was down to two hours total that last time.
Good cars but for automatics the transmission was the weakest spot. Not a bad job replacing the trans for a driveway mechanic, though. Picked up a used one for $50.
Great read! I had a good amount of experience with a similar Accord. I bought my mom a ’97 Accord LX 2-door, in the early 2000s. I wanted to get her into a modern car that got good fuel economy, as she had no need for a big car anymore. I gave her the Honda and she gave me her ’85 Olds Delta 88 which became my DD. It was a bit of transition coming from over 30 years of driving full-size RWD cars, but she grew to really like it. She even named the car. I also enjoyed driving it and got to do so semi regularly. I did all the maintenance on that Honda for mom too.
For the most part it was a pretty good car. It did have some issues when it got older, like a leaking p/s line that was rusted and seized in the p/s rack thanks to the salty winters. The copper rad corroded and needed replacement, the A/C failed and a wheel bearing failed. The clear coat failed on the paint, but the body was pretty rust resistant (better than my wife’s ’99 Civic). There were a few other minor things, and of course the regular wear items like brakes, tires, exhaust, etc. This was my first car I remember anyone in my family owning with the captive brake rotors . I can’t say that was my favorite design.
Unfortunately, this ended up being my mom’s last car. After my mom passed, we decided to give it to my sister. She drove it for a few more years, and it was passed down to my youngest brother who kept it for a brief period before it was sold off. By then it was about 14 years old and solidly in the beater class.
Nice to hear you were able to keep the car in the family. Here in our more benign winter climate, we never had any rust or paint issues with ours. My dad’s ’92 was starting to lose a little clear coat by 2003, but that was about it.
I’ve driven the road between Klamath Falls and Lakeview many times, so it was fun to see your pictures. I agree that it is a very pretty area – even the gravel
tracks are perfect roads for a stock Miata with the top down.
My in-laws are perfect examples of the attractions of Honda that led to a switch from domestic vehicles. My mother-in-law went from a Ford Maverick to a third-generation Accord, and she still daily drives a fifth-generation Accord. My father-in-law traded in his Chevy S-10 pickup for a first-generation Honda Fit, and is still driving it. Unless the have a traffic accident, they will likely drive those cars until they die.
Made it easy for me to persuade my wife to buy a 2019 Honda Insight last year – guess I need to start looking for a S2000 to replace my Miata.
It’s one of my favorite drives in the state with the mix of mountain passes and open country. Happy to share my pictures.
Just such an Accord, in just such paint, was the first car I ever saw whose owner had inflicted the then-new trend of all-clear/all-white taillights on it. It was in Eugene on 13th at Kincaid in 1997.
FWIW I’ve been married for 9 years and we’ve always had one car and we will probably always only have one car, unless I buy an older hobby car or something, and I don’t see that happening. We only have one garage space, after all.
We’re probably on the odd end of CC readership, though. We drive about 2500mi a year.
Having only one car for so long, we were definitely in the minority among our friends and acquaintances. My thinking was if we didn’t need it, why have the extra expense? We didn’t get a second car until our daughter needed one to get to school (more on that in an upcoming CC). Speaking of Miss E, she and her husband only have one car, as well. But they live near downtown Portland and there’s streetcars, buses and light rail. There are also many things within walking distance for them. They barely use the car at all.
Seeing one in that condition makes me want one even now. The color works for it. It is a very attractive car to me inside and out and probably always will be. Your photos are excellent, by the way.
I agree with the remark you made about the gauge cluster–that’s all I need right there, not the multi-display screen you see in everything now with endless messages about stuff I don’t even need to worry about. I think the Honda Odyssey at the time used the same dashboard.
I also agree with the issue about that color, and let alone when other people have almost the exact same car on the outside. There are 2 families at my church that drive Honda Odysseys, and they’re BOTH white–in addition to also having CLEMSON license plates on the front! About the only difference between the two is the wheel design. But the other thing is that GM also has a color that appears more goldish or silverish depending on the light reflecting off of it: Light Pewter Metallic. This is the color on my 2005 Chevy Astro. Another one of those “neutral” colors that’s neither conservative nor outstanding but somehow just works. But I like the fact that I can still distinguish my vehicle from everyone else’s. 🙂
My friend Hutch had a sister with a ’97 Odyssey- guess what color it was? I believe that first generation was based on the Accord platform and I recall when I rode in it once that it felt more like a tall Accord wagon than a true minivan. Dash quite different from the Accord, though gauges were somewhat similar. I really liked it because of its Accord-like qualities.
So, did the timing belt finally snap on you? Great writeup and agreed, those Ponderosas are beautiful. I sometimes wish I had bought a 96 Accord wagon instead of a 93 Camry sedan to learn stick shift on since the wagon is roomier and I hear Hondas are more fun to drive.
I missed this last week and had to come back. Yes, Heather Mist – the color of my 96 Odyssey, and seemed to me to be the color that 90% of the other Odysseys of that first generation were painted. As you say, not silver, not gold – I took to describing it as platinum. One thing in its favor – I had bought it cheap, old and with high miles, and do not believe I washed it once in the 18 months or so I had it. And you couldn’t tell!
My Oddy was killed in an accident, just weeks after getting a new timing belt. Part of the reason the service was so expensive was that most mechanics also did a water pump and some drive belts at the same time, while everything was apart.