In the spring of 2013, I was almost 47. I had (and have) a good life and much to be thankful for. There were however, a lot of “what does it all mean” moments. While it is reasonable to expect adult life and family pressures to be stressful, it seemed to be a 24/7 grind. There was not a lot of balance or fun to be had. But all that hard work (and luck) was starting to pay off. I finally had a few spare nickels rolling around. Mrs. C knew I long wanted a second, fun car, and she was supportive. I had to be fiscally responsible, so I set a budget of $10,000, as I wanted to pay cash. At the back of my mind from the start was a Mazda Miata MX-5: reliable, fun and affordable. I felt if I was going to dip my toe into the sports car realm, this would be a good place to start.
The Holy Grail Miata – That I Didn’t Get
I had my sights set on a generation NB (1997-2004). Ideally I wanted a manual, in British racing green Miata with low mileage..less than 50,000 miles. I found there was a wide variation in condition and prices of used Miata’s. The low priced ones were more often than not total sad sacks: tastelessly modified, beaten down, then rode hard and put away wet. Miata’s here are prone to tin worm, especially if left in the elements. But there were a lot of spring-summer low mileage cars out there, well-cared for by grown ups. I found and test-drove a green one at a Ford dealer in Wayne MI , good miles, asking price $7,500. I sent a friend to look at if off hours for his opinion. He texted me pictures and it had serious rust underneath. Somehow, I missed all of that in the excitement. I next drove a black, low mileage 2000 but I didn’t really want black, so I wasn’t feeling it.
I Think Miata’s Look Good Even With The Top Up
On Craigslist, I found one 30 miles west, offered by a fellow in pharmaceutical sales who was certain he would soon be laid off. A nice man, he said it was “his baby”, and it showed. Underneath, it was spotless and rust free, and you could eat off the motor. He was the third owner, and it had 41,000 miles on it. He was clearly sad to have to sell it but had other priorities. Exterior: very good from 10′ but lots of stone chips in the front fascia below the grille, but I could live with it. The interior was great except for abrasions on the left driver seat bolster from years of getting in and out and rubbing. He threw in a very nice Miata specific and branded car cover. We settled on $9,600.00 and it came home the next day. In retrospect, I think I overpaid slightly, but I did get a very nice example and I was thrilled.
Anniversary Edition Specific Blue Accents on Seats and Steering Wheel
Getting into the nitty-gritty here, but specific to the Anniversary Edition, it had: 1). a six, rather than a five speed manual transmission 2). 15” polished aluminum wheels 3). Torsen limited slip differential 4). model specific sapphire blue paint and blue Alcantara seats and trim accents 5). Bose audio 6). Bright chrome gauge rings and stainless steel scuff plates on the door sills. I’m sure I missed a few things but this is the good stuff.
The 6th gear gave it a slight improvement (7.6 vs. 7.9) in 0-60 MPH times, plus a higher top speed (130 to 133MPH), and better gas mileage (up to 35 MPG). There was a sequentially numbered badge on the driver front quarter panel. When new, Mazda threw in a special 1/43 scale model, a keychain, even his and hers Seiko watches, all in a velvet lined box, but those trinkets were long gone by the time I got it.
My Anniversary Edition Number
All in all, I thought these were tasteful , understated enhancements. It wasn’t like buying a Indy 500 pace car replica with cheesy loud colors and decals. This model does not appear to be desirable from a collectability perspective at this point. In 1999, it was $6,500 more than a base model. 7,500 copies were made globally, 3,150 for the US. It was not a sales success, and Mazda had unsold leftovers well into 2000. Somewhere along the way, a dual exhaust was added to the car and it had a great sound.
There has been a lot written about Miata’s on this site, and a COAL was written for a another 1999 NB in the not too distant past here. Suffice to say, it’s the best-selling roadster of all time for a reason. It’s an affordable, supremely well executed and balanced car. It is not neck snapping fast, but has all the speed that you can use. It’s revvy, ready and willing with just the right amound of power for the car. The handling is absolutely amazing, almost unflappable (more on that later). The shifter is excellent, with short throws and it’s very forgiving and easy to learn on.
The Miata was a very fun and enjoyable car for us. Everybody loves a ride in a convertible. It would be brought home from storage in April and put away before the first snows in mid- November. I received lots of complements on the car, and with the shimmering blue color, it was a head turner. It would drive it to work on less busy days when I had no appointments. A top down drive home was always relaxing, and I’d often take the long way. On summer evenings, my wife and I would go for drives in rural areas on quiet two lane roads, and just enjoy top-down riding and being together. It was clearly most at home there. I did not like to take it on major highways. Not that it wasn’t a nice cruiser on the open road, you just felt a bit vulnerable next to cement mixers and semi trucks.
I had to do a few things to it. When you open the Miata’s hood, it’s all there, right in front of you. So easy to work on and everything is placed thoughtfully for easy access. Even with my 10 thumbs, I was able to throw on a set of new plugs and wires on it. New Dunlap tires really helped, no telling how old the existing ones were. A few years in, one day I could not get it to go in gear and we found it needed a slave cylinder, it had a slow leak. Neither the part nor the service to install were expensive.
I did have one near miss with the car that bears mentioning. One Sunday, I punched it coming out of a left-hand turn. I am generally a careful driver, and didn’t think I hit it too hard. Shockingly…I suddenly lost control. The car started to fishtail and did a 360 on a well traveled two lane road. Luckily, there was not a car in either direction for at least a quarter mile, but had there been…it would of been a disaster for one or both of us. Pulses racing, this was a God moment and we were extremely lucky it was not a horrible accident. Suffice to say, Mrs. C was very, very angry with me. Not sure if we hit a patch of oil or if it was residual salt caused it to slide, yeah, that must of been it. Nope, on second thought I’m certain it was my stupidity. The incident did tell me to respect what the Miata is capable of.
In the summer of 2017, I decided to sell it. It wasn’t that I was tired of the Miata, or bored of it. I was not , but was ready for something different. I put it on Craigslist and after a few weeks, I had just one tire kicker and a few luke warm emails. There were at least 20 NA and NB’s for sale in our region and I found I was a little rich on the asking price of $7,500. Weeks passed and I had no more nibbles, then realized the posting expired. I put it back on at a lower price. Not long after, a buyer who sounded hot-to-trot reached out and we met barely 2 hours later with his wife. He had a 1987 Regal Grand National as a fun car at home, but the couple had an NB in the late 90’s. This clearly was a car guy. He put it on ramps he brought with him to check for rust underneath and he liked what he saw. We settled on $5,000 cash and it was gone. His wife drove it away, a huge smile on her face. I am very glad it went to a great home.
I had enjoyment of the car for almost five full summers. I like all generations of Miata’s, and think the current edition (2015-) is beautiful. Some think all Miatas, including this generation, are still too underpowered, but I disagree. There are plenty of V-8 swaps, turbo and supercharger modded Miata examples out there, but really, what’s the point of that? It’s one man’s opinion, but I think everything about Miata’s are just right as is, pure stock. In fact, I think this is one of the best enthusiast cars of all time. Suffice to say, I liked it so much that I think I would like to have another one, maybe sooner than later.
Perfect car, used exactly for its intended purpose. I use my SLK for exactly the same thing: Unwinding after a long day at work (amazing how therapeutic a top-down drive home is), and late night drives with the Mrs. I hope you replaced it with something worthy!
Still a “bucket list” car for me.
I’ve heard the 2019 with the revised engine pulls all the way to redline and very eagerly at that. Sounds perfect to me.
Thank you for this COAL.
It is said that Miata stands for Miata Is Always The Answer.
“… It’s one man’s opinion, but I think everything about Miata’s are just right as is, pure stock…”
I agree. Under most urban and suburban driving conditions, the beauty of a Miata is how it makes normal trips an experience of nicely balanced movements and sounds. It turns with minimum opposing momentum or contorting suspension components, the gears (mine has 5 speeds) allow one to wind up with little danger of attracting unwanted attention, and the feel and sound of down shifting into second before a turn is smile inducing.
“… on the open road, you just felt a bit vulnerable next to cement mixers and semi trucks… ”
Exactly. The Miata driver’s head is just about level with the axle hubs of these monsters. Feeling “a bit vulnerable” is an understatement. Also the noise level at higher speeds can get old fast on longer trips.
I’ve had mine for 20 years (bought new in November 1998). The thought of walking into the garage and not seeing it is something I am working to avoid for now. It is a little hard to get in and out as I approach age 75 and the driver’s seat side bolster shows the same wear as yours did, but once I’m in the car I’m a happy youngster of sorts.
BTW, the first year of the NB was 1999, rather than 1997, and there was no 1998 model. The 1999 NB was introduced in March 1998.
Nice story.
I desperately tried to link to your great review of a few years back of your own
NB , but my pea sized brain couldn’t quite figure out how to do that. Thanks for the clarification on the years. I’m 52 and I felt getting in and out of that thing getting progressively harder. You look to be very fit for your age. I hope you keep yours forever. I think Miata’s are the fountain of youth!
Thank you for the kind words.
My Mazda COAL chapter is at: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/cars-of-a-lifetime/coal-1999-miata-a-permanent-solution-to-a-temporary-marriage/.
And you are in good company with other CC writers as follows:
Jim Klein did one at: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/cars-of-a-lifetime/coal-1992-mazda-miata-why-did-i-not-have-one-of-these-yet-bonus-contains-coal-clues/;
Gerardo Solis wrote: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/automotive-histories/curbside-classic-1989-mazda-mx-5-miata-simple-pleasures/;
Then there is JPC’s: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/curbside-classics-asian/my-new-curbside-classic-1997-mazda-mx-5-miata-the-niedermeyerization-of-jpc-is-complete/
-and-
https://www.curbsideclassic.com/curbside-classics-asian/my-curbside-classic-update-1997-mazda-mx-5-miata-wheeeee/;
Robert Forrest did: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/blog/new-cars/future-classic-2016-mazda-mx-5-miata-a-tea-cup-sized-tempest/;
Dave Skinner wrote: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/uncategorized/cars-of-a-lifetime-1990-mazda-miata-a-member-of-the-family/;
James Pastor did: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/uncategorized/coal-1999-mazda-miata-roomy-enough-for-three/;
Roger Carr wrote: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/curbside-classics-asian/curbside-classic-1990-mazda-mx-5-miata-nothing-complicated-done-properly/;
Steven Lang pondered an odd one with: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/uncategorized/1996-mazda-miata-a-rare-idk-edition/;
Importamation added to the genre with: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/uncategorized/coal-2000-mazda-miata-all-in-the-family/;
and Tim Finn contributed: https://www.curbsideclassic.com/blog/car-show/car-show-the-answer-is-always-miata/;
and a few others that I missed but know are out there somewhere.
I see a standard-length Ford Aerostar in the background of the 2nd picture, and a white one (like my ’96; pure coincidence) at that. You were lucky to find what you got when searching for the Miata, just like with the ’05 Astro I’ve had for a month now (bought Dec. 21 last year). One SLIGHT mishap has already happened with it just yesterday: the fuel cap cover fell apart when I went to remove it to fill the tank. No apparent warning of it before, but this time I could NOT get the cap off & tried prying it open with my Fiskars titanium-blade scissors. This AT LEAST solved the problem of the cap removal. I was able to put the cap itself back on, but there would be NO chance of fixing the cover. Research leads me to believe OEM replacements are the best choice (in this case ACDelco), and AutoZone has the part in stock; I’m getting it today. There have been instances of the Check Engine light (or in the Astro’s case Service Engine Soon) coming on & off at random times (but NOT flashing) when driving the van; I’m thinking this may be the problem. Hoping to take more pictures of the van once all these little things get fixed.
The green mx-5 was a random photo online. Astros: My oldest brother has had two since 2000 and loves them. He had a 97 bought in 2000, drove to 240,000 miles, then I found a very nice 2000 w/100k miles on it on Craigslist for $4,000 for him. Perfect blend of manageable size and tremendous utility in terms of storage and towing. The 4.3 is a good motor. I’m no mechanic but the weak point seem to be front suspension . But all parts are cheap and it is very simple and easy to work on. Good luck…
Great story on a great car. My brother in law has two of the early Miatas and thoroughly enjoys them. One automatic, one stick, and no I don’t know why. Fortunately, your coolant hoses stayed intact during your tenure. There are about six of them in varied sizes and shapes and they are fun to change out.
My nephew had a beater Miata that he sold last year. In the pile of leftover parts in the garage, there was a set of aluminum wheels and a set of steel wheels. To help him out, I took them home and listed them on the List of Craig. Sold the steel ones for asking price to a guy who was going to ship them to Colombia. The aluminum ones I never did sell and eventually sold them for scrap. Interesting.
I understand everything you wrote. RL was right on the years, my 1997 model is the final year of the NA.
I have yet to drive an NB, and would guess that it is a teeny bit more refined. Mine is very elemental, which has its good and its bad points. My 5 speed could use a taller 6th gear, but I have read that the 6 speed that was available did not offer a significant change in the overall top gear ratio and that there wasn’t much point to it. Perhaps that was remedied later?
The entry-exit is indeed something that involves your entire self. Interstate highways and badly potholed roads are not the Miata’s friends. But a smooth country 2 lane with some hills and curves is a fabulous experience.
These are tremendously fun cars, having been lucky enough to drive two separate examples at different times. You’ve got me thinking of one as a future replacement for my old Ford.
While reading this, I started a mental tally of the chariots belonging (or having belonged) to the various CC contributors. I think these are the most common/popular among this contingent with Ford pickups being second. What a combination.
Everyone should try to have a Miata at one time, such great little cars, they bring the fun back into driving without trying to be anything else. And there’s one or more for every budget.
The British Racing Green one is what I wanted as well initially, followed closely by the black over red leather one. In the end mine was red with a black interior (like many others) but lost absolutely nothing in the fun it provided.
Hard to argue that the Miata is not a great car. My oldest son has a ‘92 S.E., bought in 2000 as his first car, and he still has it. Other than a few stone chips, still a stunner in Black and Tan leather.
Miatas pound for pound are simply the most grin inducing car ever built! Having owned 4, including a Mazdaspeed one, nothing I have driven has approached the driving pleasure of my Miatas. Whether simply going to pick up (a few) groceries or carving mountain roads in SE KY they are a BLAST to drive.
The only weak spot is legroom. At the 6’4″ I used to be…quite cramped. As I continue shrinking (now 6’1″) I will fit yet!! Two of my 4 were 95 first gen cars. Overall, for me as a retired Designer, I prefer the N/As for looks and driving “feel”. However, all gens are excellent lil sports cars!! :):) DFO
“The only weak spot is legroom. At the 6’4″ I used to be…quite cramped. As I continue shrinking (now 6’1″) I will fit yet!”
Getting older for the win! Right there with you…
In 1999, at the ripe old age of 22, I started working in sales at a rather large Mazda dealer. We were allocated 10 of these. And they languished on the lot. One of the main reasons that they didn’t sell well was the price: roughly $29,000 for a rag top, and nearly $32,000 for a hardtop. That wasn’t a $6500 premium over the BASE model, but over a fully loaded Miata L. This was the most expensive Miata made, by a rather large margin.
Another factor was that while many liked the exterior appearance, many also found the interior to be downright garish. (I thought it was rad though).
I think that another reason why we had so many holdovers into 2000 was that these hit our lot in May of 1999, so surely the late release was a factor. And then the stunningly beautiful 2000 SE hit our lot, which was the exact same car in a prettier wrapper for a few thousand less, making the remaining 10AM models an even harder sell. And if I recall correctly, the SE was available with an automatic, something not available in the 10AM
I personally like the blue exterior quite a lot. I was definitely more neutral on the interior bits. Garish is a great word to describe it. The blue seat inserts and soft blue plastic bits on the steering wheel aren’t for everyone. The sun was starting to noticeably degrade the finish of these items including the blue leather on mine.
In our area at the time when I bought this one, there was a bone stock red base trim NB for sale,cloth seats, just 10,000 miles on it, dealer ask was $12,000. I didn’t look at it, but that would been a cool car to have from a purist perspective. Everything you needed, and nothing you didn’t.
Due to its swoopy new curves and exposed, cat-like headlamps, the second generation Miata seemed to get an undeserved reputation as a ‘chick’ car. Personally, though, I thought they looked just fine for any gender driver and were a big improvement over the original.
In fact, I like this generation Miata the best of any of them (including the current version). My biggest issue was, as mentioned, the exorbitant premium Mazda wanted for the limited edition versions just because they had more desirable colors.
I’ve pretty much made up my mind that I’m buying a Miata next year. At that point I will be nearly 40, and that’s the age where one buys a sports car, right? 😉
My dilemma is, do I trade in my Corolla and buy a new or nearly new Miata which would be my only car, or do I keep the Corolla as a practical commuter car and buy and older Miata as a fun weekend car? I’m leaning towards the former. I just don’t like the idea of paying for insurance and registration on two cars when there’s only one of me. I don’t have kids to drive around, so passenger space is not an issue. I figure any purchase bulkier that groceries I can have delivered, especially with Amazon selling pretty much everything you could ever want nowadays, so I could probably deal with the tiny trunk. And my fear regarding older Miatas, as you alluded to in your article, is that I might end up with one that’s been abused by its previous owner.
It really depends on your finances. I think as an every day car I would not choose a Miata, unless you live in a warm weather area and do not drive much. That said, there is too little utility and too little room in the Miata. It is also not a great car to take on the interstate. If it was me, I would pay off the Corolla and then start thinking about a fun car like the Miata as a second car and not a second before. The Corolla is a car you could have easily for 10 years or longer given its reputation for reliability, low cost of ownership and durability, then look at a used Miata.
I would not worry about buying an “abused” older Miata. Learn as much as possible about the desired generation you want, and cast a wide net for a well cared for example, preferably single owner. Although I purchased mine on craigslist, there are Mazda Miata clubs everywhere and that wouldn’t be a bad place to start your search. Lastly, they are easy to work on and generally cheap to repair.
As far as insurance goes, I live in Michigan , which is about the most expensive place in the US for insurance, but even still I believe my insurance was only $700 per year. Virtually every other state would likely be less for annual premium. Especially if you have a good driving record.
If you have to have a current gen, look for a used, low mileage example. A lease return? With boats, RVs and sports cars there is often a lot of buyers remorse. For some buyers the best two days are the days they buy them and the day they sell them. A lot of people have these cars only to realize they don’t drive them enough or really can’t afford them, and dump them after a year or two so there are great deals to be had.
Good luck…and good hunting. The search is a big part of the fun, at least it was for me.
I forgot to mention that I live in California, so I have the advantage of nice weather most of the year, too (today was warm enough to wear short sleeves today). And there are plenty or roads in the Sierra foothills that I’m sure would be great fun to take it for a drive on on the weekends.
The Corolla is already 10 years old, actually, although I’m sure it has plenty more life left in it, and it already is completely paid for.
The insurance will likely be less per car if you have two cars (but more than just one). I wouldn’t worry about an abused one, there are plenty of lower mileage one or two owner Miatas out there, you can be picky and all four generations have pros and cons relative to each other.
I concur with C66 about maybe not making it your ONLY car right from the get-go, lest you turn into a buyers remorser and then want/need to unload it after a year. Better to keep the Corolla, and add an older Miata, if you end up driving it literally all the time then maybe sell the Corolla and then if things really work out maybe sell the Miata as well and upgrade to a newer one if you so desire.
Lastly, while it probably won’t haul the new 65” TV home from Costco you can still fit a surprising amount of stuff into the trunk and passenger seat area, especially if you can drive with the top down where you are.
Good luck!
Another enjoyable read Carl. My dad was looking at a new Miata about 8 years ago, as he wanted something sporty and open to fill the void after he gave up motorcycling. I went with him the Mazda dealer a few times to look at them, and they were a great fun little car. After some drives and negotiation, he ended up passing only because he didn’t think they’d be great for long distance trips (which he does a lot of in his “fun” car) and it’s very small acoomodations. He’s only around 6 feet tall and he found it snug and the trunk was also pretty small for baggage. I am taller and there just wasn’t enough leg room for me to be comfortable for in the car though.
He ended up going with a C6 Vette convertible instead, which I think is probably better for his long highway adventures. He’ll probably keep it until he has to hang up his keys permanently. While the Vette is a very capable and fast car (and surpisingly thrifty on fuel), it does feel a whole lot bigger than the spritely little Miata.
I’ve had three Miatas, a 95M I bought used, an 01 LS I bought new, and a new 2019 RF that I daily drive now. If you live simply and have winter tires they’re fine as one’s only car. They’re a joy to drive and live with (I never had a single mechanical problem with the 01 in 18 years of ownership) and they’re honest cars. Each generation has its personality and while I really liked the NA and the NB, the 19 I’m driving now is lighter, much more powerful, and just as fun while being safer and absolutely stuffed with creature comforts. You can’t go wrong with any of them in my opinion as really the only their only downside is after driving them for so long every other car feels like a dull instrument by comparison.