We’re now up to January, 2017. We’d been in Seattle for six months, and we were loving life. We had a beautiful home across the street from Lake Washington, in a wonderful neighborhood with great neighbors and a shopping center two blocks away that had everything we needed: a supermarket; a hardware store; bakery; our bank, and a Starbucks. We thought we’d camp out in my family home for six months while we looked for a place closer in town, but we decided we liked where we were so much we’d put the profits from the sale of our homes in DC and WV into remodeling rather than buy a new home.
The lease was ending our our 2014 BMW 528xi. After bad experiences with BMW, we (stupidly, as it turns out), went looking at Merecedes sedans. I really wanted an S-class, but that was too much money. We settled on a new 2017 Mercedes C-300 sedan in Selenite Gray. “Michael” (as we named him) had a turbo four engine, with enough power to meet my modest driving demands. It was very comfortable, and Nash Metropolitan tolerated laying in the back seat. We bought the Premium 3 package primarily because it had a superb sound system, important to Rick because he’s an audiophile.
If you’ve been to Seattle in recent years, you probably know we have horrible; atrocious; abominable, unspeakably bad traffic here. Seattle is shaped like an hourglass, sandwiched between Puget Sound and Lake Washington. There is one major freeway—Interstate 5—that goes north-south. Even though it’s 12 lanes wide in places, with four lanes reversing direction at noon, nowadays it is a parking lot most of the day. I used to drive the 12 miles from my family home to Rick’s apartment downtown in 15 minutes. Now, the same drive to go to Seattle Men’s Chorus practice Monday evenings takes anywhere from 45 minutes to an hour and a half. It’s the unpredictability that is most annoying: you never know when the traffic will be merely bad and when it will be a parking lot. The satellite radio and high-end sound system helped keep us sane. I’d listen to Motown or news broadcasts, and he’d listen to country or classical. Insulated in a quiet luxury sedan, we were able to keep the noisy world at bay.
A couple of years after we moved home, we received some tragic news: My older brother Jim had died suddenly. He lived on Whidbey Island, north of Seattle, in the weekend home my Dad had built—it’s the house with the ’55 Buick and ’58 Plymouth pictured in my earlier COALs. He had a form of autism, and led a quiet life mowing lawns and subsisting on disability. We weren’t terribly close, but I did what I could to help him financially, and that included helping him with transportation. I’d given him my ’72 Pinto in 1976, and purchased a couple of pickup trucks over the years for his gardening work. Alas, Jim never took care of things; he couldn’t deal well with challenges like home repair or car repair. In 2012, I paid $3,000 to put a new engine into his truck—the old one had failed because he never had it serviced. Now that he was gone, his house and 2008 Dodge Dakota became mine.
Rick and I decided quickly to sell Jim’s house. It was in terrible shape, and we didn’t want the expense and bother of fixing it up and maintaining a second home. The truck was another matter; I couldn’t bear to part with it. It was disgustingly filthy, and needed work. So I spent some time detailing it and giving it long-overdue service. The mechanic told me it would need a new transmission and brakes soon. I held off on that, figuring I’d only use the truck for occasional trips to Lowes or the garden center to haul things that wouldn’t fit in the Mercedes. And it was kind of nice to have a second car. I’d use it to help friends move stuff around; I once took a chorus friend and his husband along as we hauled some of their old household items to a recycling center. It was quite comical to see Niels, who is 6’4″ tall, contorting himself into the jump seats in the crew cab.
After about six months, the transmission in the pickup began to fail; it wouldn’t upshift from first to second, or I couldn’t get it to shift out of neutral. Much as it broke my heart to sell a part of my brother’s life, I took it to a Ford dealer and walked away with $3,000. On a whim, I checked the local Mercedes dealer and found my second midlife-crisis car: a 2017 SLC AMG convertible.
The SLC was the vroom-vroom AMG edition. It had a twin-turbo four and high-end underpinnings. It was super fun to drop the top and cruise on into It’s Better Than Ever Street. It was also wildly impractical. Seattle, as you may know, is cursed with cold, grey, drizzling rain six months out of the year. Not at all top-down weather. With the top down, you had room for a toothbrush and an extra pair of sunglasses in the trunk, and not much more when the top was up. And with only two seats, we could not go anywhere if the dog came along: Rick refused to carry Nash on his lap when we went to visit our friends on Camano Island, but he acquiesced to my purchase. A key to success in any long-term relationship is knowing when to let your spouse buy stupid, expensive stuff. I kept my mouth shut when he spent $40,000 on a new sound system when we moved to Seattle after retirement, so he bit his lip and kept quiet when I bought the SLC.
Alas, the joy was short-lived. Two months after purchase, the car began squealing from the left front wheel when braking. It wasn’t just loud, it was cats-howling-at-the-moon loud. I took it back to the dealer and had them replace the brakes under warranty. That lasted about six months, but then the problem returned. When I went back to the dealer they tried the “It’s a high performance car, Steve, of course the brakes are noisy” line on me. But I stuck to my guns and had the brakes replaced at their cost again. Six weeks later the fan in the HVAC system refused to work, so back I went yet again to get that fixed.
By March of 2021, the brakes started acting up for a third time. I talked it over with Rick, and found that the dealer had a 2017 C300 Cabriolet for sale. Back I went to the dealer and insisted they take the car back and give me the C300 to replace it. I pointed out that “Certified Pre-Owned” meant nothing if you had to replace the brakes every six months. Despite being very amiable most of the time, I can get very, uh, forceful if I’m wronged. After a tense standoff, the dealer gave me a decent offer on the SLC and I walked away with a 2017 C300 convertible. They even refunded the unused portion of my extended warranty.
The C300 was a lovely shade of dark blue, which is my favorite color. From certain angles, the humped rear window and raised rear deck reminding me of the ’48-’54 step-down Hudsons, so I named him “Hudson”. It didn’t have the vroom-vroom go of the SLC, but it did have a back seat, which meant we could go places with the dog. And we could go grocery shopping and bring home a full week’s worth of food, so it was much more practical than the SLC.
This was the era of COVID. The Seattle Men’s Chorus had shut down early in the pandemic—one of our singers is an ER doctor who treated the first COVID patients. He urged us to shut down everything early; 200 men sitting in close proximity singing and spewing aerosolized particles is a huge risk. Good thing, too; a week after we shut down, a singer who sits near me came down with COVID and nearly died. So with that part of my life on hold we basically sat at home for the rest of the year, and neither of our cars got much use. I spent the next year singing my parts into a computer at home and then techno-whizzes would stitch it all together to make a video of us singing together. When we started up singing again in 2021, we’d sit six feet apart. Three of us crammed into Hudson and drove 90 miles to Sequim to get our first covid shots in March 2021. Mike (center), who sat in back, was rather stoic about the cramped quarters. On some day-long rehearsals, when we’d break for lunch, we’d head to my car. I’d put the top down to minimize the risk while we munched our lunches.
I loved driving Hudson. He gave us great service, but by 2022 his warranty was expiring, and I knew keeping German cars past the warranty expiration date was problematic. Besides, I’d kind of gotten the must-have-a-convertible thing out of my brain, so it was time to move on. I’ll talk about that, and what we did with Michael, the C300 sedan, in my final chapter.
Previous chapters:
- Buicks Aplenty; a Fiat, and a Pontiac • The Early Years.
- 1958 Plymouth Custom Suburban • Dad’s Biggest regret.
- 1965 Buick Sportwagon • My first car.
- 1967 Datsun 1600 • The first car that was legally mine.
- A Pair of Pintos.
- 1983 & ’87 Toyota Celica • What’s the Plural of ‘Celica’?
- 1987 Ford Taurus MT-5 • Tragedy, An Unexpected New Car, And Two Midlife Crises
- 1987 Jeep Cherokee and ’96 Grand Cherokee • Entering the SUV Era
- The BMW Era
You have been performing a great public service here, by becoming The Guy who dives into the BMW and Mercedes experiences so I don’t have to. 🙂 Actually, it is good to have reached a point in life where I can see someone enjoying a shiny, desirable new/new-ish car and can be happy for you getting what you enjoy, while at the same time not having the slightest urge to get something similar for myself. But I can certainly see why each of them attracted you.
I am sorry about your brother. That had to have been a difficult situation, but it sounds like you did what you could. I understand how the grungy pickup could tug at the heart, but I don’t blame you for not signing on for the new transmission.
This has been a very good series, especially seeing how someone else around my own age has navigated the different times of life through this series of vehicles. I am sorry to see this one coming to a close.
Squeaky brakes are a common complaint with the R172 SLK/SLC. I mentioned the problem my COAL, as did some commenters. I’ve had the brakes looked at several times and have been assured that they are fine, so I’ve just learned to live with it.
https://www.curbsideclassic.com/cars-of-a-lifetime/coal-2016-mercedes-benz-slk300-the-upgrade/
Wow! I missed that COAL piece, or I would have linked to it in mine!!!!
I hear you about the seats….. they were super comfy!
Thanks Steve for another great chapter.
Your pictures of the SLC and to a somewhat lesser extent the C300 make the point to me that those cars are just so much more attractive with the tops down than up. I see a lot of SLCs in my area and of course being as it’s New England, the tops are more often up than down; and I find them rather ungainly-looking with the top up. Top down, it’s a very different look. I can see though that the opportunities for top-down motoring are probably as limited in Seattle as they are in my corner of the country.
It’s interesting about the traffic in Seattle. I have friends who live out there, having lived before in DC and they too note that the traffic is almost as bad as it was in DC. Nevertheless, the opportunity to walk to a lake and swim in the evening close to half the year seems to take some of the edge off of putting up with what they head-shakingly describe as some legendary bad driving. I can get that (about the lake part at least).
Unlike you, I don’t know if I could have resisted the siren song of having an inherited (i.e., free to me to acquire) pickup truck around. I might just have shelled out for the transmission so as to have something in the driveway that can handle all of the stuff that a homeowner might use a truck for.
For years we would come to see Dad in September for his birthday. He would gripe incessantly about the traffic. But since we never really went anywhere we missed most of it. We’d just laugh and say “you haven’t experienced I-66 going west from DC at rush hour!” That is, until we actually moved here. Just like Dad, we seldom leave our cushy, sheltered suburban enclave on the Lake.
Last week I had to go downtown five times in one week for Seattle Men’s Chorus rehearsals and performances of our spring concerts. The night Rick attended we drove together. It took us 70 minutes to go 12 miles from our house downtown. 60 of those minutes were on the 10-mile stretch of I-5 between where we get on and our exit downtown. Rick decided to go to sleep to avoid the angst of the traffic.
I hope you guys have found Lexus by now! Owning modern cars should not be such an ordeal!
In my experience, owning previously owned upscale vehicles has been more gratifying, reliable and affordable.
Great series so far. Curious to know what kind of sound system Rick got (also somewhat of an audiophile). I know they all look similar, but I swear Micheal looks like an E300, not a C300. The headlights are a dead giveaway for me
Actually, you’re right….. it was an E 300. Oops!
Rick has a NAD amp and pre-amp with six foot tall speakers the brand of which I don’t know. All that’s hooked up to a Sony NAD music server with music from 1,200 ripped CD, plus a SONY Blu-ra UHD DVD player, Oppo CD player, and 60 inch OLED TV. Between the to of us we have over !,000 vinyl LPs in the attic and no turntable to play them. We could fit a LOT more stuff in the attic but Rick refuses to think about selling the LPS and getting rid of the boxes the stereo gear came in. That perplexes me, but I’ve learned some battles are not worth fighting.
They’re beautiful cars, and exceptional high-speed highway cruisers. I’ve always admired the german mid-sizers, they’re the right size, classy, and all drive well. Being the risk-averse person I am, I ended up with a GS350. It might not be as quiet and solid feeling as the germans, but it’s been dead reliable for 9 years and 200,000+km. Fingers crossed…
That’s quite the audio system Rick has, very nice! That’s funny, I also still have the boxes my gear came in. Ditto the countless CD’s and LP’s. Just can’t part with any of it!
Love reading this! And now I have “Freeway of Love” stuck in my head 🙂
I am very fortunate my wife is as patient with me as she is when it comes to the cars…and I made sure to get the extended warranty on our 2017 XTS from Carvana. It’s come in very handy – the CUE screen and one of the seat vibrator motors had to be replaced, and all we paid was the deductible.
As far as car audio systems…I’m with Rick. Also why I want to trade the XTS in on a XT6…we took one for a test drive and I loved the sound system.
I think the appropriate observation is: jumping from the frying pan into the fire!
S-Class? …well at least you dodged that bullet.
As always your posts are Simply 🎶the 🎶 BEST🎵 blending personal life with car reviews. This one strikes several familiar chords. When my father passed in 84 (mom in 83) I faced the choice of moving to the family home (which had been in the family for approximately 100 years) or staying in my own. Although I had helped keep them and the property going for several years, the house needed much work. With some regret, I sold it to a young couple who have done so much to restore and expand the house and grounds. There are still many flowers planted by my grandmother. Recently passed on some antiques original to the house. Their appreciation for the history is truly gratifying. Apparently those of us named RICK have issues with figuring out how to drive a Mercedes. My late brother had numerous vehicles including Cadillac Series 75(long story),and ROLLS-ROYCE Silver Cloud, Silver Shadow, and Corniche. Then for some reason I NEVER understood, he switched to Mercedes. Believe he had five before passing. On one occasion he borrowed DADS Volare wagon and left his 450SL. Dad was not driving much. After Mom’s passing, I frequently took Dad to run errands and out for lunch. Dad said, We might as well use that damn Mercedes. Having worked for INLAND STEEL, he had little regard for foreign vehicles. It took me ten minutes to figure out how to turn on AC and other accessories (marked with symbols beyond my comprehension). We got about three miles when Dad asked to return home and get my BUICK, with plush seats more comfortable for his fragile body. GLADLY obliged. The 450 became sister-in-laws car and brother had three two seat converts until his passing. ALL Mercedes were trouble prone!
Hi, I bought a brand new 1970 250C Mercedes coupe, first year of this body style, loved the pagoda styling on roof similar to the two seat sports model. The car reached the H temperature setting in ten minutes – when I took it back to dealer I was told it was only getting ‘broken in’ and to not worry. Long story short the car always overheated, the dealer was no help at all, had problems one after another, big expense after expense in the miserable 3:years I kept it, hoping one of the various mechanics I took it to could solve the problem(s), finally gave up & bought a wonderful reliable Toyota Celica – never again any German product for me.
It only has to happen once:
… Faulty new car + bad dealer service = goodbye forever.
” – never again any German product for me… “
… Same here; including the specified brand.
“Give us another chance” they say?.
… Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me.
We bought a new model year 2020 domestic manufactured van. Late model, and still low mileage by my standards at about 33K, but ZERO issues. Unfortunately the windshield cracked badly from a rock impact, and the (US made) replacement caused us to lose the “Union Made by UAW Workers” sticker that came on it originally.
I believe there was a time when “luxury” meant that a car was built with more thoughtfulness and care in both design and construction. I’m talking about Cadillac until the late 60s and Mercedes until the late 80s.
Somewhere along the line, the definition of “luxury” changed to mean more toys and more technology – and quality was let slip in the name of profits. I’ll contend with my last breath that the last truly great Mercedes was the W126, whose production ended in 1991.
” … quality was let slip in the name of profits.”
Evan, I agree. I’d even make a small addition to this statement:
Quality and service were let slip in the name of profits.
They all sound like solid choices to me and the E class and E class coupe/convertible are neat cars in my book.
“I knew keeping German cars past the warranty expiration date was problematic” – whilst your experience may be different, this is not the UK perception of any German car – VW, Audi, BMW, M-B or Porsche. We’d maybe link it to a French or Italian but not a German one.
Another great installment in your automotive saga.
I moved to Seattle in 1978. I love it here, but… As the saying goes, Seattle is an hour away from Seattle.
Whereabouts in Seattle? Sheridan Beach/Lake Forest Park here. I-5 to 145th to 522 to home at any time after 2:00 PM is a nightmare. 😛
Nowadays, I’m in Kenmore, just a short bike ride on the Burke-Gilman trail to Third Place Books in LFP. That’s the first thing I think of when someone says “Lake Forest Park.”
Hah! In all the years my house was there, I never heard that, but it is utterly true and correct.
The worst new car I have ever had was a 2022 Mercedes AMG E Class wagon – horrible paint, numerous problems with transmission, headlamps that did not work on main beam and first braking from 220kph on the Autobahn sent it completely sideways. In addition the reversing camera was installed 90 degrees out of whack. Handled horribly with over sensitive steering, harsh front suspension and way too soft rear. Loud, unrefined Diesel motor. Interior contrast stitching was wobbly, too, just to add insult to injury in this 80,000 Euro sled. Asked friends in Stuttgart that had Mercedes products and they said that this is seemingly the norm.
A horrible vehicle that I returned after about 200km…
Being an Audiophile myself I can assure you that your husband’s peculiarities are the norm. Now if he decides he needs to turn your entire basement into a subwoofer it’s probably time to seek out professional help.
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://gizmodo.com/horn-subwoofer-takes-up-crazy-mans-entire-basement-5025867&ved=2ahUKEwiH6ezpmMT_AhUWmGoFHfgsADUQFnoECBIQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1JWWh8iWdXpYpXsQyfvXgG
I wonder can’t you simply drive the 12 miles on surface streets ? .
When the Harbor freeway gets backed up I get off and detour through South Central Los Angles, never had any problems yet .
My middle sister wanted to treat herself to a BMW convertible, the entire rest of the family yelled at her for “! BING SO STUPID !” so she asked me, I said buy the newest lease return one you can find and the *instant* you don’t like it anymore get rid of it .
She did and loved the car, she lives in Richmond, Va.and loved driving it with the top flopped .
I caution everyone to avoid German cars new or old can’t miss using this advice .
Their older Motocycles seem okay though .
-Nate